Russia, are you serious? Women's 1500 Meter results

If you know me well then you would know that I hate being skeptical of others, especially when there is no proof of wrong doing. However today I could not keep my mind from wondering with results I saw on the IAAF World List. 

I was browsing around to see what marks were looking like around the world and when I pulled up the women's 1500 I saw an overwhelming number of Russian women towards the top....more specifically 8 in the top 13. All the times ranged between 3:59 and 4:02 while six of those times were in the same race held in Moscow on June 13, 2012. Before this race there had only been nine women around the world to run under 4:04. One of the women, Elena Soboleva, ran consecutive races of 4:00 and 4:01 within four days at Moscow (results) and Zhukovskiy (results), respectively.

Screenshot of current IAAF list:



Let's take a look at the eight athletes that rocked such high caliber times over the four day span. Four of the athletes set PRs over more than six seconds. One athlete, Ekaterina Poyistogova, had no results from prior to 2012 (with the expection of an indoor 600m in Dec of 2011) but runs 4:00...literally out of no where (See update below). Two athletes, Elena Soboleva and Tatyana Tomashova, served over 2.5 year bans for doping incidents before the 2008 Olympic Games. The IAAF rules around the ban stated that there was "fraudulent substitution of urine which is both a prohibited method and also a form of tampering with the doping control process" (article here | updated article months after). Tomashova was the 2003 and 2005 World 1500m champ along with the 1500m silver medalist at the 2004 Olympics. Soboleva earned the silver medal at 1500m in the 2006 World Indoor Championships. In 2007 she won silver at World Outdoors and gold at 2008 World Indoors, however both results were erased due to her ban....along with her indoor 1500m World Record of 3:58.05. Only one woman of the eight did not PR.

Take a look at the breakdown below:

Name Age  PR before '12 (Yr)     Previous SB       Result Location Notes
Svetlana Podosenova 24 4:12.03i ('11) 4:07.26 3:59.61 Moskow 12.42 sec PR from previous years' best
Ekaterina Gorbunova 23 4:01.02 ('11) 4:09.16 3:59.89 Moskow 1.13 sec PR  from previous years' best
Ekaterina Poyistogova 21 4:18.82 ('09) 4:18.4 4:00.11 Zhukovskiy Thanks to twitter, know she was formerly Ekaterina Zavyalova but got married.
18.71 sec PR  from previous years' best
No results before 2012 found, huge PR.
12.90 sec PR from indoors.
Elena Soboleva 29 3:56.43 ('06) 4:12.74i 4:00.33 Moskow Fastest time since 2006. Served a 2 year, 9 month ban from 7/31/08 to 4/30/11. Results from 4/26/07 to 7/31/08 were disqualified. 
Suspended right before Beijing Olympics where she was one of the favorites.
Kristina Khaleeva 24 4:08.79 ('09) 4:05.67 4:00.53 Moskow 8.26 sec PR from previous years' best
Elena Arzhakova 22 4:07.69 ('11) 4:06.06 4:00.82 Moskow 6.87 sec PR  from previous years' best
Won Euro Champs 800 this summer. Ran 1:58.77 in 800 in 2011. Former steeple chaser.
Tatyana Tomashova 37 3:56.91 ('06) No Result 4:01.95 Moskow Fastest time since 2006. Served a 2 year, 9 month ban from 7/31/08 to 4/30/11. Results from 4/26/07 to 7/31/08 were disqualified.
Suspended right before Beijing Olympics.
Ekaterina Martynova 25 4:01.68 ('11) No Result 4:02.75 Zhukovskiy Ouside past dopers, only athlete on list to not set a new PB. Semi-finalist in 1500 at Daegu WC in '11

After seeing the results on the IAAF website I received an email from Race Results Weekly stating three Russia athletes were banned "through the use of the biological passport program" (see article here). I immediately checked the names but none matched to any of the women above, although two were middle distance runners and the third a marathoner. I investigated into these women and their past results (using tilastopaja.org). These are interesting findings and make you very wary during an Olympic year. The Russian Championships are going on right now and I have already noticed that the slowest time to qualify to the finals of the 800 was 2:00.13....six of the eight ladies qualified are under 2:00 (Results here).

I have called out Russia here but I am fully aware that even our own country, the United States, is regarded as a hot bed for dopers due to many of the sprinters being busted especially over the last 10 years. I always hope for the best and want to believe everyone has the best intentions but we have seen through past history that this isn't always the case. I just hope the distance clouds hovering over the Olympic year don't bring down a storm on our already troubled sport.



Additions: Here is a chart mapping how many athletes over the years have run under certain marks, Russians vs the World total

Year Russians
sub-4:05
World
sub-4:05
Russians
sub-4:02
World
sub-4:02
Russians
sub-4:00
World
sub-4:00
Notes:
2004 7 37 5 11 2 7
2005 7 22 5 11 4 7
2006 8** 25 5 11 3* 5 *All of these women
were banned in 2008
**2 more of these
women were banned
2007* 4 14 0 5 0 1 *7 Russian banned
before Olympics.
2008* 5 24 0 7 0 1 *7 Russian banned 
before Olympics.
2009 7 32 3 12 2 8
2010 3 34 1 14 1* 7 *Alminova served a 3
month suspension in 2010 
2011 8 37 3 12 0 0 No Russian broke 4:01
2012 9 23 7 12 2 5



Additions: I have added a chart that looks at every Russian women who has run under the current Olympic A standard of 4:06.0. I have tried to add additional marks for events that seemed to be strong points for that athlete.


Name PR Doping Allegations? 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
Tatyana Tomashova 3:56.91 Banned from 7/31/08 to 4/30/11. Marks from 5/23/07 disqualified 3:58.12 3:59.05 3:56.91 *4:05.48 *4:10.48 Ban Ban 4:03.69 4:01.95
Natalya Evdokimova 3:57.73
3:59.05 3:57.73 N/A N/A 4:04.19 3:59.66 4:04.56 4:03.33 4:11.11
Olga Yegorova 3:59.47 Banned from 7/31/08 to 4/31/11. Marks from 4/7/07 disqualified 4:01.15 3:59.47 4:01.31 4:04.64 Ban Ban Ban Ban N/A
Gulnara Galkina 4:01.29
4:01.29 N/A N/A 4:03.31 4:03.31 4:02.34 N/A (9:29.75sc) 4:12.82
Yelena Zadorozhnaya 3:59.94
4:01.38 4:03.65 N/A N/A 4:04.88 N/A 4:07.69 (15:05 5k)
(8:41i 3k)
4:14.85
Liliya Shobukhova 4:03.78
4:03.78 4:07.03 4:03.90 (1:11:14 half marathon debut) 4:08.11 (30:29 10k)
(2:24 marathon debut)
(2:20:25 marathon) (2:18:20 marathon) N/A
Yuliya Fomenko
(Chizhenko)
3:55.68 Banned from 7/31/08 to 4/30/11. Marks from 4/27/07 disqualified 4:04.58 3:58.68 3:55.68 Ban Ban Ban Ban 4:10.22 4:15.57i
Elena Soboleva 3:56.43 Banned from 7/31/08 to 4/30/11. Marks from 4/26/07 disqualified 4:11.98 4:01.14 3:56.43 Ban Ban Ban Ban 4:06.64 4:00.33
Elena Kanales 4:02.23 Banned from 2/26/09 to 2/25/12. Marks disqualified 4:09.94 4:02.66 4:02.23 4:12.73i 4:09.32 Ban Ban Ban Ban
Liliya Bikbulatova 4:05.67
(2:04.34) 4:05.67 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A
Natalya Panteleeva 4:00.81
4:13.57 4:13.84 4:00.81 4:03.2 4:02.56 4:03.92 4:11.27 N/A N/A
Anna Alminova 3:57.65 *Banned from 4/9/10 to 7/8/10. Marks from 3/12/10 disqualified 4:10.30 N/A 4:04.72 4:03.10 4:02.02 3:58.38 *3:57.65 N/A N/A
Olga Komyagina 4:02.32
N/A 4:12.85 4:05.24 4:04.5 4:07.82 N/A N/A N/A N/A
Ekaterina Martynova 4:01.68
(2:05.94) 4:15.56 (2:00.85) 4:15.81 4:05.06 4:05.40 4:09.46 4:01.68 4:02.75
Yelena Sidorchenkova 4:05.77
4:12.47 4:08.78 4:10.08 4:12.27 4:05.77 4:11.58 N/A N/A 4:13.39
Oksana Zbrozhek 4:00.86
4:14.75i
(1:58.06)
4:08.16 (2:02.13) 4:11.35i
(1:58.80)
N/A 4:00.86 4:04.91 N/A N/A
Yevgeniya Zolotova 4:02.49
N/A (2:00.78) (2:00.10) (2:02.34) (2:03.9) 4:02.49 4:08.25i 4:05.47 4:10.74
Yuliya Zaripova 4:04.59
N/A (2:05.44) N/A N/A (9:54.9sc) 4:04.59
(9:08.39sc)
4:10.50 4:07.01
(9:07.03sc)
N/A
Natalya Popkova 4:05.86
N/A N/A (16:26 5k) 4:16.19 4:10.57 4:05.86 4:09.98 4:07.40 (15:26 5k)
Ekaterina Gorbunova 3:59.89
N/A N/A N/A 4:17.55 4:14.91 4:10.78 4:13.63 4:01.02 3:59.89
Ekaterina Kostetskaya 4:01.77
(55.55 400H) (55.89 400H) (56.75 400H) (1:59.52) (1:56.67) (1:59.31) (2:01.19) 4:01.77
(1:57.19)
4:04.97
(1:59.03)
Olesya Syreva 4:02.73
4:18.54i 4:07.78 4:06.47 4:14.12i (15:19 5k)
(1:09:52 Half Marathon)
4:10.90i (1:13:24 Half Marathon) 4:02.73
(1:10:18 Half Marathon)
(1:12:19 Half Marathon)
Anastasiya Vosmerikova 4:03.59
(2:06.96) N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 4:06.67 4:03.59 (2:42.59i 1k)
Anna Konovalova 4:03.92
N/A N/A N/A N/A (2:03.67) N/A 4:17.32i
(2:01.54)
4:03.92
(2:02.24)
4:20.31i
Yuliya Rusanova 4:05.14
N/A N/A N/A (2:03.74) (2:01.2) (1:58.99) (1:59.85) (1:56.99) (2:00.26i)
Svetlana Podosenova 3:59.61
N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 4:12.03i 3:59.61
Ekaterina Poyistogova (Zavyalova) 4:00.11
N/A N/A N/A (2:06.96) (2:04.96) 4:18.82
(2:02.11)
(2:04.33) (2:02.64) 4:00.11
(1:57.93)
Kristina Khaleeva 4:00.53
N/A N/A N/A N/A 4:10.78
(2:03.0)
4:09.79 N/A 4:13.73 4:00.53
(2:00.38)
Elena Arzhakova 4:00.82
N/A N/A (10:12sc) N/A (10:37sc) N/A 4:08.05
(9:49sc)
4:07.69
(1:58.77)
4:00.82
(1:58.77)

Kenny Bednarek Makes History With 19.82/44.73 Double At JUCOs

One day after riding a blustering tailwind to the fastest wind-aided 200m in history, Indian Hills freshman Kenny Bednarek decided to give wind legal a try on the final day of the 2019 NJCAA Outdoor Track and Field Championships. The result? Still damn fast.

Shanghai Diamond League: Lyles Stuns Coleman, Samba Tops Benjamin

The second leg of the 2019 Diamond League season made its stop in Shanghai, China, on Saturday, and it was jam-packed with marquee matchups and tight finishes.

Kenny Bednarek Runs Fastest Wind-Aided 200m In History

If you’ve ever wondered how fast a world-class sprinter could run with a comically strong tailwind, Indian Hills Community College freshman Kenny Bednarek had your answer on Friday with his 19.49 200m (+6.1 m/s) in the 2019 NJCAA Track and Field prelims.

What Did It Take To Qualify For NCAA Prelims Over The Years?

Since the NCAA moved to a two-regional system in 2010, the qualification process for the NCAA Championships has consisted of the top 48 individuals and top 24 relays in the West and East regions competing for 12 qualifying spots during the last weekend of May.

Unlock this article, live events, and more with a subscription!

Get Started

Already a subscriber? Log In

Samba/Benjamin Pt. I, McLaughlin Debut Headline Shanghai DL

The first six-ish weeks of the professional track season have offered one clear lesson: the late World Championships aren’t going to tamp down fast times. From Michael Norman’s 43.45 to Shaunae Miller-Uibo’s 49.05, it’s feeling like mid-August already. Perhaps the non-championship year in 2018 caused some energy and emotion to be bottled up, only being released in a year with a clear championship target. 

Unlock this article, live events, and more with a subscription!

Get Started

Already a subscriber? Log In

Schneider, Praught-Leer Notch 5k Olympic Standards At Oxy

(c) 2019 Race Results Weekly, all rights reserved

NCAA Prelim Entries Reaction: Six Scratches You Need To Know

With Wednesday’s release of the NCAA East and West Preliminary Round declarations, we now know the 48 athletes in every individual event and 24 relay teams that will compete in Jacksonville and Sacramento for a spot at the NCAA Championships in Austin.

House Of Run: Evaluating The U.S. Performance At World Relays

Jason and Kevin discuss Matthew Boling’s epic weekend, the struggles of the US at the World Relays, Mondo Duplantis’ collegiate record, a big NCAA upset, an American record in the 25K and this weekend’s Shanghai Diamond League.

Infinite Tucker's SEC Superman Dive Deserved An Article

The following is an actual conversation between FloTrack writers Kevin Sully and Lincoln Shryack regarding Infinite Tucker’s Superman dive to win the SEC 400m hurdles title over the weekend.

Mondo Breaks Collegiate Record, Roberts Upsets Holloway

Ever since Mondo Duplantis stepped on campus at LSU, breaking the collegiate record seemed inevitable. That’s a logical assumption when you vault 6.05 meters en route to a gold medal at the European Championships before you begin your freshman year.