Nike Offered Berian Reduction-Laden Contract

Today in federal court, lawyers for world indoor 800m champion Boris Berian filed the terms of Nike's initial offer to Berian in February. Nike and Berian have been locked in a fascinating legal battle for the last month over whether Berian is obligated to sign with Nike or free to compete for New Balance.

At the crux of Berian's lawyers' argument is the rights of first refusal clause of his 2015 contract, which allows Nike to match the specific written terms of any third-party offer presented to Berian for up to six months after his initial contract ended on Dec. 31, 2015. Matching an offer from another sponsor would trigger a new endorsement agreement between Berian and Nike. 

But Berian's lawyers are asserting Nike did not match the terms of the new offer. New Balance's proposed contract did not include reductions, but the version Nike sent back to Berian did. As a result, they contend it did not match, and therefore did not trigger a new contract with Berian.

Here are the terms of those reductions, per the filing:

First and foremost, 10 of Nike’s “Standard” terms is a nine-part reduction provision allowing Nike to “EXTEND, REDUCE, AND PRORATE” Mr. Berian’s compensation. Id. at p. 6-7. It says that Nike may “in its sole discretion” reduce Mr. Berian’s compensation in any or all of the following ways:

(a) by withholding some or all base compensation if Mr. Berian fails to compete for 120 days (or simply terminate if he fails to compete for 180 days);
(b) by withholding base compensation, bonuses, and travel reimbursement during any period of review by any anti-doping organization;
(c) by a reduction of 25% to 50% if Mr. Berian does not compete in at least 10 IAAF or USATF sanctioned competitions during any contract year;
(d) by a reduction of 20% if Mr. Berian is not ranked in the top 10 worldwide for the 800 meter event, and by 25% if Mr. Berian does not compete in a “major outdoor championship”—even if the reason he does not compete is a failure to qualify;
(e) by withholding bonuses and up to a 25% reduction in base compensation if any thirdparty (including, for example, the International or US Olympic Committees, or any of their broadcast partners) “enforces or threatens to enforce any regulation, restriction, prohibition or practice that deprives NIKE of the promotional benefits and/or product/brand exposure contemplated by NIKE’s use of the ATHLETE Endorsement inany advertising or promotion”;
(f) by a reduction of 20% per missed meet or press conference if Mr. Berian “for any reason does not compete on behalf of NIKE in, or attend a press conference at, either one or both of the Prefontaine Classic or the Penn Relays (or, at NIKE’s discretion, alternate NIKE-sponsored competitions)”;
(g) by a reduction of 25% per occurrence if Mr. Berian covers or obscures “(including, without limitation, through the placement of any numbered or other bib) any NIKE Marks on any NIKE Products” that he is wearing or using, or if he wears any “tattoos” with any third-party marks, names, or identifications;
(h) by a reduction of 25% for any failure, “for any reason” to wear NIKE Products at any and all athletic or athletic-related activities (including, per p. 2, during competition, training, press conferences, camps, autograph sessions, interviews, etc.); by 25 % for any missed appearance, after the first in each contract year)


In addition, Berian's legal counsel is arguing Nike’s purported match was not even a contract in the first place—it was "an agreement to agree," meaning they believe Nike did not intend its offer to be the final contract. In their filing, Berian's team specifically cited these excerpts from Nike's letter, among others:

“This letter is to notify you that NIKE matches the New Balance Offer … and will enter into a new contract with Boris for the exclusive right and license for his ‘Athlete Endorsement’ in connection with the ‘Products’ and/or NIKE brands (as each is defined in the [2015 Contract]) and otherwise in accordance with the matched terms….”

Confirming the point that there were terms yet to resolve, Nike added: “we will send to you a new contract which will include the stated terms of the New Balance Offer as received.”

Furthermore, his lawyers wrote that because he did not enter a formal agreement with New Balance during this period, he did not violate the six-month rights of  first refusal period. To avoid being sued, Berian remained unsponsored during this timeframe. 

Nike's rights of first refusal will expire on June 28, 2016.

We'll have more on this story soon, and you can read the full filing below.

Here is the full news timeline of the ​Nike v. Berian case:

Boris Berian Gets Served By Nike for Breach of Contract
Nike Seeks Federal Court Order to Stop Nike From Wearing New Balance
Report: Nike Wins Restraining Order Against Berian
Boris, Nike Approaching Potential Resolution?

Berian's filing of full Nike offer

Five Burning Questions For The 2019 World Cross Country Championships

null

Join PRO Now to Get Unlimited Access to FloTrack!

Join Now

Already a PRO Member? Log In

The 43rd edition of the IAAF World Cross Country Championships is this Saturday, March 30, in Aarhus, Denmark. A hilly and eclectic 10,000m course awaits the senior men and women, and below I’ve tried my best to answer five of the most pressing questions entering this weekend’s championship races.

Holloway Debuts, Kenny B's Back, Another ASU Star Thrower Emerges

It’s still the early days of the outdoor season, with athletes regrouping from the indoors and slowly trickling into the spring season. This weekend’s action was light, especially compared to next weekend’s trifecta of big meets at Stanford, Florida and Texas, but there were some notable results.

Talented ADP Squad Likes World XC Medal Chances On Tough Aarhus Course

null

Join PRO Now to Get Unlimited Access to FloTrack!

Join Now

Already a PRO Member? Log In

When Shadrack Kipchirchir lines up for the 2019 IAAF World Cross Country Championships on March 30 in Aarhus, Denmark, the 30-year-old American is hoping for the nastiest weather that the Danish city can provide.

Join PRO Now to Get Unlimited Access to FloTrack!

Join Now

Already a PRO Member? Log In

Here's Why USATF Honoring World Rankings Would Be A Disaster

Earlier this week we published an opinion stating why it is a good thing for USATF to use time standards as the only means to guarantee a spot on the 2020 U.S. Olympic team. Our main reason was based on the fact that the new world rankings are unfair, but more importantly, the world rankings make the selection process even worse.

CAS Delays Semenya Decision Until Late April

The Court of Arbitration for Sport announced on Thursday that they will push back a ruling in the case involving Caster Semenya until late April. 

House Of Run: Everything To Be Excited About In The Outdoor Season

Jason and Kevin discuss the 42 most interesting storylines heading into the outdoor season. How healthy is Wayde Van Niekerk? Who will be the top women's 1500m runner? Can the Jamaican men win a sprint medal? What will Eliud Kipchoge do for an encore? Will this be the year of the 400m hurdles?

The Best Track And Field Athlete From Every NCAA Tournament School

The 2019 NCAA DI Men’s Basketball Tournament begins this week, and in honor of March Madness we’ve selected the best track and field athlete— past or present— from each of the tournament’s 68 schools (minus Old Dominion, who does not have a track team; get a track team Old Dominion). Some of the names below are NCAA track and field legends from major programs. Others on this list never even qualified for the NCAA Championships. The 68 here ran the gamut, from Olympic heroes to mere school record holders.

Why LetsRun Is Wrong & USATF Is Right About Olympic Qualifying

Last week, the IAAF announced its new qualification process for the 2020 Olympic Games, which included tougher entry standards and new computerized world rankings. The reaction was intense as some media outlets painted an apocalyptic worldview for U.S. athletics. In reality, it’s not that dramatic.

Cal Coach Tony Sandoval To Retire

Tony Sandoval, the director of track and field and cross country at Cal, will retire at the conclusion of the outdoor season. Sandoval spent 37 years at the university, beginning as the head women’s coach in 1982. 

Six Reasons We're Looking Forward To The NCAA Outdoor Track Season

As exciting as 200-meter ovals and banked curves are, we’re ready for the unpredictable weather, sprint relays and 10K races of spring track season. Here’s a few reasons to get excited for NCAA outdoor track and field.