IAAF Releases New Study As It Tries To Reinstate Rules On Testosterone

A new study published this week in the British Journal of Sports Medicine found that elite female track and field athletes with higher levels of testosterone enjoy a 1.8 percent to 4.5 percent competitive advantage over women with lower testosterone levels, especially in the 400m, 400m hurdles, 800m, hammer throw, and pole vault events.

The blood samples in the study were pulled from male and female athletes competing at the 2011 and 2013 World Championships in Daegu and Moscow, excluding individuals who were found to have hyperandrogenism or hypoandrogenism.

The report, titled "Serum androgen levels and their relation to performance in track and field," was authored by Dr. Pierre-Yves Garnier, director of the IAAF Health and Science Department, and Dr. Stéphane Bermon in support of the IAAF appeal to the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS), which two years ago suspended the IAAF rule on limiting female athletes' naturally occurring testosterone levels.

"If, as the study shows, in certain events female athletes with higher testosterone levels can have a competitive advantage of between 1.8-4.5 percent over female athletes with lower testosterone levels, imagine the magnitude of the advantage for female athletes with testosterone levels in the normal male range," Bermon commented. 



The suspended IAAF rule, adopted in 2011, required female athletes with naturally occurring testosterone levels above 10 nanomoles per liter of blood to undergo hormone therapy to artificially lower that number. The testosterone limit was created in response the success of Caster Semenya, the South African phenom who became a world champion over 800m as an 18-year-old in 2009 and later found to be hyperandrogenic.

The 10 nmol/L limit is generous, for, according to the IAAF, the 99th percentile of female track and field athletes report testosterone levels of just 3.08 nmol/L.

When the IAAF first introduced the rule in 2011, Semenya underwent the required hormone therapy and quickly saw her times slow, though she still managed to win a silver medal at the 2012 London Olympics.

The issue resurfaced in 2015 when a hyperandrogenic Indian sprinter named Dutee Chand refused to undergo hormone therapy and appealed her ban to the CAS, which ruled to null the IAAF's rule for a period of two years during which the organization would be required to gather evidence proving the unfair advantage of hyperandrogenic athletes. Since the CAS overturned the IAAF rule, Semenya has been unbeatable over 800m and won Olympic gold in 1:55.28, a personal best and her fastest time in seven years.

null

The main point of contention between the CAS and the IAAF is that there is no overwhelming evidence that suggests hyperandrogenic women's biology presents a distinct advantage over women with normal hormone levels. The following is from the Chand decision, which you can read in its entirety here.

"It is not self-evident that a female athlete with a level of testosterone above 10 nmol/L would enjoy the competitive advantage of a male athlete, which performance advantage would be, on the IAAF's evidence, in the order of 10-12 percent (the approximate difference, on the evidence of the IAAF, between men and women and, therefore, an unfair advantage), rather than, say, 1 percent (a relatively marginal advantage, having regard to the many other variables that contribute to athletic performance)."

The CAS will make a decision at the end of the month whether or not to reinstate the IAAF rule, and thus force Semenya, Chand, and other intersex athletes who are currently protected to either undergo hormone therapy or quit the sport.

"This study is one part of the evidence the IAAF will be submitting to CAS regarding the degree of performance advantage that hyperandrogenic female athletes enjoy over female athletes with normal testosterone levels," Bermon said. "We continue to gather more data and research on our journey to providing a fair and level playing field for females in our sport."

South African sports scientist Ross Tucker offered a take on his blog, The Science of Sport, contending that the new study likely does not demonstrate enough of an unfair advantage in hyperandrogenic athletes to sway the CAS:

"...people trying to argue that these intersex athletes are females with a normal genetic advantage, just like Lebron James, Usain Bolt and Michael Phelps are basically arguing for the dissolution of female competition, they just don't realize it yet. However, because this argument is so pervasive, it will come up in the CAS hearing. And here, the IAAF evidence is not quite strong enough to refute it.

"Had the IAAF discovered a performance advantage of 6 percent to 8 percent, then it's different, because that's close enough to the 10 percent male-female difference that I think you could make a case for it being an advantage that 'outranks the influence of any other single genetic or biological factor'... 2 percent to 5 percent, in my opinion, DOES still meet that criteria, and I believe it to be even larger in virilized women with [Disorders of Sex Development]. However, I don't know that it will be enough for CAS, given how often they referred to the 10 percent to 12 percent male-female difference in their conclusion previously."

The upcoming CAS ruling will not affect the IAAF World Championships in London, where both Semenya and Chand will be allowed to compete, but the decision will set the standard for all future IAAF and IOC competitions.

Talented ADP Squad Likes World XC Medal Chances On Tough Aarhus Course

null

Unlock this video, live events, and more with a subscription!

Get Started

Already a subscriber? Log In

When Shadrack Kipchirchir lines up for the 2019 IAAF World Cross Country Championships on March 30 in Aarhus, Denmark, the 30-year-old American is hoping for the nastiest weather that the Danish city can provide.

Unlock this article, live events, and more with a subscription!

Get Started

Already a subscriber? Log In

Here's Why USATF Honoring World Rankings Would Be A Disaster

Earlier this week we published an opinion stating why it is a good thing for USATF to use time standards as the only means to guarantee a spot on the 2020 U.S. Olympic team. Our main reason was based on the fact that the new world rankings are unfair, but more importantly, the world rankings make the selection process even worse.

CAS Delays Semenya Decision Until Late April

The Court of Arbitration for Sport announced on Thursday that they will push back a ruling in the case involving Caster Semenya until late April. 

House Of Run: Everything To Be Excited About In The Outdoor Season

Jason and Kevin discuss the 42 most interesting storylines heading into the outdoor season. How healthy is Wayde Van Niekerk? Who will be the top women's 1500m runner? Can the Jamaican men win a sprint medal? What will Eliud Kipchoge do for an encore? Will this be the year of the 400m hurdles?

The Best Track And Field Athlete From Every NCAA Tournament School

The 2019 NCAA DI Men’s Basketball Tournament begins this week, and in honor of March Madness we’ve selected the best track and field athlete— past or present— from each of the tournament’s 68 schools (minus Old Dominion, who does not have a track team; get a track team Old Dominion). Some of the names below are NCAA track and field legends from major programs. Others on this list never even qualified for the NCAA Championships. The 68 here ran the gamut, from Olympic heroes to mere school record holders.

Why LetsRun Is Wrong & USATF Is Right About Olympic Qualifying

Last week, the IAAF announced its new qualification process for the 2020 Olympic Games, which included tougher entry standards and new computerized world rankings. The reaction was intense as some media outlets painted an apocalyptic worldview for U.S. athletics. In reality, it’s not that dramatic.

Cal Coach Tony Sandoval To Retire

Tony Sandoval, the director of track and field and cross country at Cal, will retire at the conclusion of the outdoor season. Sandoval spent 37 years at the university, beginning as the head women’s coach in 1982. 

Six Reasons We're Looking Forward To The NCAA Outdoor Track Season

As exciting as 200-meter ovals and banked curves are, we’re ready for the unpredictable weather, sprint relays and 10K races of spring track season. Here’s a few reasons to get excited for NCAA outdoor track and field.

FloTrack To Stream 2019 Boston Marathon In Europe

AUSTIN, Texas — March 18, 2019 — Today, FloSports, the innovator in live digital sports and original content, and the Boston Athletic Association, announced a partnership to provide live and on-demand coverage of the 2019 Boston Marathon on FloTrack.com exclusively in over 40 European countries. 

Ethiopia's Belay Tilahun, Not Included In Elite Field, Wins NYC Half

(c) 2019 Race Results Weekly, all rights reserved