The Biggest Upset Of The World Indoor Championships May Be The Line Judges

BIRMINGHAM, ENGLAND (2-March) — A sloppy morning session on Day 2 of the IAAF World Indoor Championships saw 12 men disqualified, including the United States' gold medal hope in the men's 3K: Olympic silver medalist Paul Chelimo, whose third-place performance in the heats was invalidated for taking one step outside the rail.

That Chelimo lost his balance due to the jostling and tight nature of the men's pack up front doesn't matter, nor does it matter that he gained no conceivable advantage from the single step outside the rail.

It only matters that he took the step on the curve of the track and not the straight.



USATF will not protest the decision, representatives from the organization confirmed this afternoon.

The seemingly senseless DQ is similar to the one handed down to Colleen Quigley last summer after she qualified to the steeplechase final at the world championships.

"It's devastating," Chelimo said after he learned of the decision. "It's an indoor track and it's banked and we're running 15 laps, what do you expect? It's not going to be 100 percent — someone is going to lose a step. And it happened today, it was me who lost a step. 

"Whatever I was doing was not intentional. . . . I stepped inside the rail by mistake."

The ironic part is that Chelimo's disqualification opened the door for his teammate, Shadrack Kipchirchir, to advance to the final. The 10K specialist, widely believed to be a potential medal contender, fell off the pack in the first section after being jostled.

"Unfortunately, it's not... I'm not happy for this," Kipchirchir said. "I would not be happy for being disqualified for cutting in. I don't like it that way. I'm not happy about it. When I go to the final, I'll fight til the last minute, give all I got. I'm going to be 100 percent for sure, but that is not what I wanted. He's my buddy. To DQ him and put me in instead... I would rather stay here, but I cannot do anything."

Chelimo said he is happy that Kipchirchir will run the final, yet could not help feeling overwhelmed with disappointment.

"I qualified the right way," he said. "I was top four, that's what I worked for. I did not get any advantage by stepping inside the rail. The rules are rules. . . . I cannot bend the rules."

Below is a full list of athletes disqualified today. Only three delegations (Grenada, Costa Rica and Germany) filed protests on behalf of their athletes; all were rejected.

EventAthlete (Country)Reason
3KPaul Chelimo (USA)Curb Infringement
3KKemoy Campbell (JAM)Curb Infringement
3KYoussouf Hiss Bachir (DJI)Curb Infringement
3KRichard Ringer (GER)Athlete Obstruction
400Bralon Taplin (GRN)Lane Infringement
400Steven Gayle (JAM)Lane Infringement
400Abdalleleh Haroun (QAT)False Start
400Austris Karpinskis (LAT)Lane Infringement
400Alonzo Russell (BAH)Lane Infringement
400Nery Brenes (CRC)Lane Infringement
400Miriama Senokonoko (FIJ)Lane Infringement
400Maja Ciric (SRB)Lane Infringement

The onslaught of disqualifications brings to mind last night's women's 3K final, in which Sifan Hassan of the Netherlands arguably impeded Laura Muir in the homestretch by running out from lane one to lane three so the Scot was unable to pass her for the silver medal behind Ethiopia's Genzebe Dibaba.

After the race, Hassan denied knowingly impeding Muir and claimed "when I'm tired, I cannot control my body." 

Watch Hassan's post-race interview below:

Sifan Hassan Doesn't Remember Drifting Out Of Her Lane


Muir said she did not remember being impeded.

You can watch the controversial finish in the tweet below by forwarding to 0:25:



An official from British Athletics said today that the organization did not file a protest on Muir's behalf.

It's interesting that the line judges were so scrupulous with the rulebook this morning, yet saw no reason to indict Hassan — though her behavior clearly bears at least consideration of IAAF Competition Rule 163.2 (b), which states "if another athlete is found by the Referee to be responsible for the jostling or obstruction, such athlete (or his team) shall be liable to disqualification from that event."

The women will race again in the first round of the 1500m tonight.

Will today be the apex of DQs and poor line calls?

Or are there more technical upsets to come? 

Stay tuned...

NCAA DIII XC Recap: North Central Wins No. 19 In Rout, WashU. Scores Upset

Join PRO Now to Get Unlimited Access to FloTrack!

Join Now

Already a PRO Member? Log In

Race Replay: 2018 DIII NCAA XC Championship Men's 8k

A shocking upset in the women’s race and a dominant performance by the winningest men’s program in NCAA cross country history told the story on Saturday at the 2018 DIII NCAA XC Championships in Oshkosh, Wisconsin, as the Washington U. women beat two-time defending champs Johns Hopkins by one point, while the North Central men won their 19th DIII title with their lowest point total since 1993.

Morgan McDonald Reigns, NAU Three-Peats At NCAA XC Championships

Join PRO Now to Get Unlimited Access to FloTrack!

Join Now

Already a PRO Member? Log In

Race Replay: 2018 DI NCAA XC Championship Men's 10k

MADISON, WI. — The men's NCAA DI XC Championships made history on Saturday morning as Wisconsin senior Morgan McDonald became the first man to win the individual title on his home course since 1992, and Northern Arizona became the first team to win three consecutive team titles since 1998.

Champion Dani Jones Leads Colorado To NCAA XC Team Title

Join PRO Now to Get Unlimited Access to FloTrack!

Join Now

Already a PRO Member? Log In

Race Replay: 2018 DI NCAA XC Championship Women's 6k

MADISON, WI. — You couldn't write a better story for Colorado senior Dani Jones, who captured her first individual cross country national title while leading the Buffs to their first team championship in 14 years.

Coast Guard's Kaitlyn Mooney Eyes NCAA History At DIII XC

When Coast Guard sophomore Kaitlyn Mooney crosses the finish line Saturday at the 2018 DIII NCAA XC Championships in Oshkosh, Wisconsin, there’s a very good chance she’ll have accomplished a feat that no other woman has in NCAA history.

Loyalty To Team Is The Driving Force At NCAA Cross Country Championships

(c) 2018 Race Results Weekly, all rights reserved

MADISON, Wisc. (16-Nov) -- Morgan McDonald has worn the Australian colors in five global championships, and placed eighth at last April's Commonwealth Games in the 5000m on home soil.  But the 22 year-old senior from Sydney, who will be running his final cross country race tomorrow for the University of Wisconsin, said those championships don't compare to tomorrow's NCAA Division I Cross Country Championships here when it comes to his drive to succeed as a member of a team.

2018 DIII NCAA XC All-American Projections

NCAA XC: Dynasties On The Line

Below are FloTrack's 2018 projections for the men's and women's DIII NCAA XC All-Americans:

Former NCAA Stars Make Their XC Predictions

NCAA XC: Dynasties On The Line

Watch the 2018 DI NCAA XC Championships LIVE on FloTrack, Saturday Nov. 17th!

DIII NCAA XC Women's Preview: Hopkins Hones In On Dynasty

Workout Wednesday: Johns Hopkins Men & Women

The 2018 DIII NCAA women’s cross country championships will feature a favorite in Johns Hopkins looking to expand on their recent dynasty, and a slew of challengers seeking to put an end to the Blue Jays’ dominance. Hopkins will race for their sixth title since 2012 on Saturday in Oshkosh, Wisconsin, a run that only one other DIII women’s program in history has accomplished. It should be fascinating to watch it all unfold in brutal cross country conditions this weekend.

Deep Field Tries To Take Down New Mexico, Kelati Goes For First Title

NCAA XC: Dynasties On The Line

It didn’t take long for the narrative of the women’s NCAA cross country season to shift. New Mexico entered the fall with three of the nation’s best runners, high profile transfers, and a clear line to their third team title in four years. 

NCAA XC Champs Confidence Picks: NAU Three-Peats, McDonald Edges Fisher

The stakes are clear and the storylines are well established.