The Challenge Of Doubling, Irrelevant Seed Times & Other NCAA Takeaways


Grant Holloway stole the show, while Florida and Arkansas walked away with team titles. But what were some of the other takeaways from Birmingham? 

The First Three Legs Of The DMR Do Matter

When the difference between first and second place in a nine-and-a-half minute race is .15 seconds, then it’s reasonable to look at all the possible reasons for that tiny margin. Notre Dame edged Stanford in the men’s distance medley relay, 9:31.55 to 9:31.70, buoyed by Yared Nuguse’s late burst that thrust him ahead of Grant Fisher. But it was actually Fisher who had the faster anchor leg, a 3:54.24 to Nuguse’s 3:56.03. 

Entering the final leg, both teams were chasing Iowa State who had about a seven-second lead on the main chase pack (which included Notre Dame) and another two seconds back to Stanford. Both groups made up ground, erasing Iowa State’s lead. With 250 meters remaining, Fisher passed Nuguse, setting up the dramatic final lap. 

The benefit of hindsight opens up all possibilities. If Fisher had received the baton one second behind Notre Dame instead of two, would he have been able to hold off Nuguse? Did the effort he took to make up the gap take enough out of his legs for the finishing kick? That scenario would have invited in all sorts of new variables with tactics, positioning, etc. that’s it hard to say for certain. Nuguse is a smart, experienced runner who could have adjusted on the fly. But it’s not a crazy proposition that a faster split from the first three runners could have helped Stanford squeeze out that .15 seconds. 

It’s become en vogue to call the distance medley relay a mile race. In some cases that’s certainly the case. At the very least, the race is weighted heavily toward the final leg. However, there are instances when the other three legs are critical, even if it is just a fraction of a second.  

Doubling (and tripling) Is Hard

Grant Holloway, Morgan McDonald and Jessica Hull made it look easy but doing multiple events in a two day meets is a grueling venture. Oliver Hoare looked like the walking dead after running the 3000m final (his fourth race of the competition). He entered the race in order to help Wisconsin’s teams chances, but said he knew he didn’t have it after two laps.

Weini Kelati handled the 5000m/3000m double well, taking second and third. But Wisconsin’s Alicia Monson showed how difficult it is to complete those races in less than 24 hours. She looked invincible on Friday night, kicking away from Kelati in the final lap to win her first NCAA title. The 3000m the next day promised to be more difficult with the presence of Hull, but it was surprising that Monson wasn’t able to stick with pace and eventually slid back to 10th place. 

In the sprints, Kayla White of NC A&T won the 200m and finished second in the 60m hurdles. Obi Igbokwe of Houston had an incredibly busy weekend with the 200m, 400m and 4x400m on his plate. He finished fifth in the 400m, eighth in the 200m and somehow still had enough left to contribute a leg to Houston’s winning 4x400m team.

After the race, his teammate, Kahmari Montgomery, showed just how hard these championships can be.

Seed Times Meant Nothing In The Running Events

In individual events 400 meters and up, not a single top seed won their event. In fact, in the entirety of the women’s competition on the track, USC’s Chanel Brissett in the 60m hurdles was the only winner who entered the meet with the best mark. This speaks to the unpredictability of the meet, and the indoor season as a whole. 

But the more bland takeaway is that many top athletes, particularly distance runners, are simply racing to qualify for the meet and thus, their seed time isn’t all that indicative of their potential. Morgan McDonald wasn’t the top performer in either the 5000m or 3000m during the season, but there was a very good chance he would win at least one race in Birmingham. Same with Jessica Hull of Oregon. The middle distance races were destined to be a jumbled mess, especially after the scratches in the women’s mile. The men’s mile became equally open when Oliver Hoare of Wisconsin embarked on his triple. 

The two legitimate upsets where the seeding looked to hold arrived in the women’s 400m and men’s 800m, though in retrospect, there were reasons to question both. Lynna Irby’s qualifying time came at the last possible meet, and her status as the favorite (and sizeable favorite) had more to do with what she’d done in June than this winter. The 800m is always hard to forecast, and when you factor in Devin Dixon’s struggles in championship meets, it wasn’t surprising that Bryce Hoppel was able to take advantage.  

Seed Marks Did Mean Something In The Field Events

It was the opposite in the field events, and particularly for the men. Led by big favorite Payton Otterdahl and Mondo Duplantis, the top seeds won the shot put, weight throw, pole vault, high jump and long jump, while the No. 2 seed won in the triple jump (the top seed did not start the competition) and heptathlon. 

The women’s field event deviated a bit, but the athlete with the best mark did win the pole vault, triple jump, women’s weight throw and pentathlon.

There Is No Clear Women’s Sprint Star

Entering the meet, there was a vacuum in the women’s sprints and hurdles. Coming off 2018 when the NCAA was filled with collegiate record holders like Sydney McLaughlin, Aleia Hobbs, and Gabby Thomas, it was expected that this year wouldn’t have that same level of depth. Instead, we got parity. There were plenty of new and young faces in the sprints and hurdles--a sign that this is a transition year, or at the very least, a transition season. Whether or not that continues outdoors will be one of the stories to follow throughout the spring.

Who Should Run On The U.S. Men's 4x100m?

As long as they can avoid the tragic fate of many a past U.S. men’s relay teams, the Americans should win 4x100m gold in Doha this October. Of course, that’s not at all a guarantee with Team USA registering a slew of DQs over the years, but a much weaker Jamaican squad without Usain Bolt has the Americans in position to finally regain the top global spot in the 4x1 for the first time since 2007.

Rabat Takeaways: Ethiopia Beginning To Make Noise In Steeple

The Diamond League was back in action on Sunday as the international track and field circuit made its annual African stopover in Rabat, Morocco.

Unlock this article, live events, and more with a subscription!

Get Started

Already a subscriber? Log In

Kenny B, Welcome To The Diamond League: Rabat DL Preview

The second Diamond League meet of the week takes place on Sunday in Rabat, Morocco with Genzebe Dibaba, Salwa Eid Naser, Nijel Amos, Emmanuel Korir, Jenny Simpson and burgeoning American sprint star Kenny Bednarek all in action. Here are five events to watch. 

Unlock this article, live events, and more with a subscription!

Get Started

Already a subscriber? Log In

Confirmed: Grant Holloway Now Sponsored By Adidas

June 14 update: It's official! Grant Holloway is sponsored by adidas.

Oslo Diamond League Recap: Coleman Goes 9.85, Lewandowski Shocks Mile

The Diamond League was in Norway on Thursday for its annual stop at the Bislett Games in Oslo. Upsets were aplenty in the distance races, while speedy U.S. stars Christian Coleman and Sydney McLaughlin picked up impressive victories.

Unlock this article, live events, and more with a subscription!

Get Started

Already a subscriber? Log In

POLL: Which 3 Men Should Be Bowerman Finalists?

Now that the NCAA season has wrapped (and quite spectacularly so at the Division I outdoor championships), it's time to reflect on the most outstanding performers and narrow in on the top candidates for the 2019 Bowerman Award.

'SPEED CITY' Episode Six Debuts LIVE On June 14th At 6PM CT

This season, we debuted our season-long series, "SPEED CITY: A Season With The Houston Cougars," which follows the Houston men's track and field program as they pursue their first-ever NCAA team title. 

A Running List Of College Athletes Going Pro In 2019

It's that time of year! We're keeping this page updated to highlight which collegiate stars are turning pro and where they're going. 

Katelyn Tuohy Decides To Shut Down Season After Long Year

After a long calendar year which included a national cross country title, national indoor titles in the 2-mile and DMR and a third straight New York State Championship in the 3K, North Rockland High School junior and defending Gatorade National Athlete of the Year Katelyn Tuohy has decided to shut her season down. 

POLL: Which 3 Women Should Be Bowerman Finalists?

Now that the NCAA season has wrapped (and quite spectacularly so at the Division I outdoor championships), it's time to reflect on the most outstanding performers and narrow in on the top candidates for the 2019 Bowerman Award.